Is Alcoholics Anonymous More Effective Than Cognitve Behavioral Therapy?
Question by abnjim5: Is Alcoholics Anonymous more effective than Cognitve Behavioral Therapy?
Much debate exists about which model is more effective in treating the problem of drug addiction. Some say AA is the only treatment that “works” while others choose the more human friendly non-religious CBT. AA uses rigid spiritual concepts based on their 12 steps and conducts their AA meetings on strict formats that were written seven decades ago. In AA “labels” like alcoholic are used which still holds a high degree of social stigmatism. Cognitive Behaviour programs like SMART (self-management and rehab treatment) sees substance abuse as a behaviour that can be changed, not a disease. CBT self-help methods are solidly based in comtemporary science and open discussions are encouraged. AA tells it members and “newcomers” that they need to find a higher power or god and relying on “self will” is bad and will lead to relapse.
If you were having problems with drugs, which would you choose for help, AA or CBT?
Best answer:
Answer by synchronicity915
I think it depends on the person.
Answer by dinoduos
AA is a bunch of BULLSH!T its nothing but a bunch of drunks leaning on each other trading one crutch for another you dont need them or a “higher power”its like another form of brainwashing
What do you think? Answer below!
Drug defendant convicted
Defense attorney John Kirwan said his client has nearly completed a substance abuse treatment program at Firelands Counseling & Recovery Services. Since Duncan “is doing well,” Huron County Assistant Prosecutor Richard Woodruff said the state …
Read more on Norwalk Reflector
Allen County plans new court for veterans
Unlike doing hard jail time, offenders are given a chance to get treatment for their substance-abuse problem, group counseling, as well as having a court-appointed case manager to whom they report. Gull said the only thing they ask when an … Gull …
Read more on News Sentinel
Obama policies could stifle Md.'s biotech industry
One proposal would impose price controls on the Medicare Part D prescription drug program, and the other would shorten the amount of time innovative companies have to potentially recoup the enormous investments made in discovering new treatments …
Read more on Baltimore Sun